Both of the (A–series) sub-categories just
mentioned include an objective Present, but Presentism specifically
assumes that only Present objects exist. The Growing Block Universe
assumes both Present & Past objects exist, but no Future
objects yet exist. So to the singular Present of Presentism the Growing
Block Universe adds a real Past (which increases as a “growing”
block), though neither accepts a reality for the not-yet occurring Future.
So while there is no objective Present in
the (B-theory), there is a “friendlier” general attitude toward the Future.
The (B-theory) in turn has it‘s own (not exactly contrasting or
separate) over-lapping subdivisions of Eternalism [which confusingly preceded the above (A-theory)
“growing” block in being also called the Block Universe but just not
“growing”] & an also closely related
4–Dimensionalism. Without putting too fine a point on it,
the essentially identical terms (B-theory) terms Eternalism &
Block Universe, precede, but then were later confirmed by the 4–Dimensionalism
of Einstein’s Special Theory of Relativity (SR). [McTaggart &
Einstein published at similar times, but the former was not yet familiar with
the later.] Einstein’s SR depicts
a “static” 4-D Space-Time. Here, the Future, designated relative to a
specified Observer, claims the same ontological status as some distant
point in Space.
Eternalism (just prior to SR) was a philosophical
approach to the ontological nature of Time. Eternalism took the
view that all points in Time as equally "real", as opposed to the Presentist
idea that only the Present is real. Philosophy’s Eternalism or
the equivalent 4–Dimensionalism of Relativity Physics
means that Time is just another dimension. Future events are
"already there", & that there is no objective flow of
Time. It was sometimes referred to as the "Block Time" or "Block
Universe" theory, due to its description of Space-Time as an unchanging
4-D "block", as opposed to the view of the world as a 3-D Space
“modulated” by a “passage” of Time. [But again, this differs from the
later-named “Growing Block Universe” of the (A-theory) that is not Presentism.]
Reviewing again that (A-theory) Presentism,
we note again that there are only the events & entities in the Present,
along with some timeless objects or ideas like numbers & Mathematical sets.
These latter additions are also taken to occur & exist in the Present.
Furthermore, for Presentism, the so-called events & entities that
are wholly Past or wholly Future do not exist at all.
The (A-theory) Presentism contrasts
with the (A-theory) Growing Block Universe & also contrast
with the (B-theory) Block Universe, more usually called Eternalism,
or more clearly called 4–Dimensionalism. Cutting across
both (A-theory) & (B-theory) we see that Growing Block
Universe & Eternalism, respectively are the Metaphysical theories
that extends to Future events. Referring back to the early centuries
A.D., we saw that Augustine spoke of the Present “knife edge” between Past
& Future which itself could not not contain any “extended”
period of Time. Injecting that concept into pure Presentism (without a
“growing” Block of the Past) would dissolve Time as essentiall un-real,
according to the even more ancient doctrine of the “3-Times” described earlier.
But the “Father of Psychology” William James argued
that conscious experience is naturally extended in Time, in that there is
"the short duration of which we are immediately & incessantly
sensible". With his own earlier form of Presentism, James further
concurred that: "everything Past is unreal, everything Future is
unreal, everything imagined, absent, or mental is unreal. Ultimately real is
only the Present moment of physical “efficiency” which we would now call
“efficacy”. The latter refers to the ability to participate on as a “cause” in
Causation, Cause & Effect.
The above themes & 1600 pages more are freely available as perused or downloaded PDF’s, the sole occupants of a Public Microsoft Skydrive “Public Folder” accessible through:
The above themes & 1600 pages more are freely available as perused or downloaded PDF’s, the sole occupants of a Public Microsoft Skydrive “Public Folder” accessible through:
or with Caps-sensitive:
Duplicates have been available on:
jstiga.wordpress.com/
[But from now on, they will be different & still usually daily.]
"There is no Creation, no Destruction, no Bondage, no longing to be freed from Bondage, no striving for Liberation, nor anyone who has attained Liberation. Know that this to be Ultimate Truth." – the "no creation"school
of Gaudapada , Shankara, Ramana, Nome
– Ajata Vada
for very succinct summary of the teaching & practice, see: www.ajatavada.com/
"There is no Creation, no Destruction, no Bondage, no longing to be freed from Bondage, no striving for Liberation, nor anyone who has attained Liberation. Know that this to be Ultimate Truth." – the "no creation"
for very succinct summary of the teaching & practice, see: www.ajatavada.com/
No comments:
Post a Comment